Wright is justified in refusing his principal’s speech. At the time of Wright’s graduation, Wright had discovered his passion for writing and was more than capable of writing a coherent speech. When he wrote his speech, it contained Wright’s own thoughts and emotions. Presenting his own speech freed Wright on some level, for it allowed him to voice his concerns and hopes to a large audience, recreating how he felt when he read his short story to his neighbor. The principal wrote Wright’s speech so that nothing vaguely disputable would be presented during graduation, but this seems both rude and cowardly on the principal’s part.
Refusing Wright’s speech is insulting because Wright had toiled in his studies to be able to present a speech at graduation. The principal should have recognized these achievements and trusted Wright to write a competent speech. The principal also forced his speech upon Wright because he feared Wright’s speech would be too radical. The principal wanted to please the whites in the graduation audience and convince them of the school’s neutrality towards the black race. His speech was canned, unemotional, and uncontroversial, and Wright’s speech was true. Wright wanted to speak the truth and share his intelligence and so justly refused the “bought (176)” principal’s speech.
Monday, March 2, 2009
Sunday, March 1, 2009
Uncle Tom's Anger
Uncle Tom wants to beat Wright for being “a sassy black imp (157).” Wright had told his Uncle Tom that the time of day was about 5:18, and "If it's a little slow or fast, it’s not far wrong (157).” Tom feels greatly disrespected by such a reply and decides that Wright needs be whipped. Wright is angry with Tom because he feels he’s being beaten for a misdemeanor, something trivial and small. As Wright writes in the text, “… I was going to be beaten by someone who did not like the tone of voice in which I spoke… How long was I going to be beaten for trifles and less than trifles (158)?” Wright is made angrier by the fact that Tom is a new member of the Wright household and has never been involved in Wright’s life before this residency. It seems unfair that a man Wright was not raised by can beat him. When Wright sees his uncle stripping a tree branch to beat him with, he explains, “Now, listen, Uncle Tom, you’re not going to whip me. You’re a stranger to me. You don’t support me. I don’t live with you (159).” The scene ends with Wright using razors to protect himself against his uncle’s whip. When Tom relents to Wright’s razors, Wright tells his uncle, “You are not an example to me; you could never be… Your life isn’t so hot that you can tell me what to do (160).” Perhaps Wright is also angry with Tom because Wright doesn’t want to be disciplined by a man he cannot respect, a man who “weaves the bottoms of chairs for people to sit in (160).”
Thursday, February 26, 2009
Writing
Wright, suppressed by his mother’s lashes and his grandmother’s religion, is finally able to express himself through writing. He creates a story that whispers of “longing and death (120),” thoughts and feelings Wright had been burdened by because of his mother's paralysis. Hiding these thoughts was draining and unhealthy for Wright. It excites him to pen the story for it is something of his own, infused with his own emotions and worries. “There was no plot, no action, nothing save atmosphere and longing and death. But I had never in my life done anything like it; I had made something, no matter how bad it was; and it was mine… (120).” It pleases him to share the tale because it allows him to communicate with another human being a topic higher than food and punishment. By reading his story to his neighbor, Wright tells her his feelings, but not in an overly open, uncomfortable way. He is “sharing with her the burden of his existence,” as Patricia Hampl wrote, and he finds it greatly gratifying.
Tuesday, February 24, 2009
Paralysis
When Wright first discovers his mother’s paralysis, he is shocked and unable to understand her condition. During Wright’s turbulent young life, his mother had remained a constant presence, a woman who, even after his father’s abandonment, stayed strong. Her strength makes her illness “seem unthinkable.” (85) Now, Wright’s rock has crumbled, leaving Wright stunned and silenced. He becomes emotionally withdrawn from his family members, especially his mother, whom he cannot bear to talk to, look at, or tend. He refuses to eat food and is embarrassed when he is forced to eat or when comments are made about his unhealthy weight. He wishes he were older, so he would not have to rely so on others. Wright is simply unable to cope with his mother’s paralysis, a drastic change in his life. His mother had been his voice-of-reason when Wright was in trouble, and she had tried to be his provider of food and affection. Her illness pierces Wright and leaves him unsure of himself and his future. He is fearful of her death, and this fear and uncertainty pins him to silence and numbness.
Monday, February 23, 2009
Heritage
Wright admits that, as a child, he and his friends were “poor, half-starved, ignorant, victims of racial prejudice.” (61) Wright, his friends, and their race were regarded with disgust from white people. Both white people and black people looked upon Jews with disgust. Wright taunted Jews because it was an acceptable way for him to vent his racial frustrations. Although unsure of why he held such strife, Wright disliked white people. He disliked their constant access to food and their violence against black people. Wright disliked Jews because they had “killed Christ.” Harassing Jews at the local grocery was a way to unleash this hatred upon a race, which, generally, was disliked by both warring parties. Wright had no true reason for his cruelty. Vaguely, without real thought or reason, Wright does it to pass time in a way that won’t inspire his mother to beat him, but, truly, Wright torments Jews to unreel racial anger that usually boils quietly, unexplained and shapeless, inside.
Saturday, February 21, 2009
Hunger
As a young child, Wright’s life is bereft of true joy. He achieves superficial, brief happiness by drinking and engaging in nefarious activities. However, when the soap letters are wiped from the windows, when his drunkenness wears away into sobriety, he is left hungry and empty. Wright is hungry because his life is empty, both literally and figuratively. Sustained on bread and tea, Wright is constantly seeking a morsel of something, but nothing is to be found, and so he sleeps and lives with an empty stomach. Figuratively, Wright has no father and no real home. He is given no love from his father and is shown only snippets of kindness from his mother, who is tired from failure. His first home dies in a fire, and the flat in Memphis is scarred with unhappiness. The orphan home serves as a shelter, not as a place of security. Wright’s life has no path and no potential purpose. His hungriness represents emptiness of the body and of the soul.
Thursday, February 19, 2009
School's Out Forever?
Gatto’s essay was quite fascinating. I know little about the history of America’s schooling system and was interested to find out that it is based off of Prussia’s schools. That being said, I think Gatto is mildly insane. The concept that America’s schools are “laboratories of experimentation on young minds, drill centers for the habits and attitudes that corporate society demands” (159) is absolutely ludicrous. I think America’s schooling system needs to be rethought and reformed, yes, but Gatto’s statement borders on conspiracy and paranoia.
I absolutely believe that schooling is necessary. Twelve years of it is extreme, but elementary and secondary schools are certainly essential. As Gatto mentions, schools teach their pupils to respect authority and follow directions, skills necessary to maintain jobs. He fails, though, to recognize that schools provide an environment in which to learn social skills and acquire friendships. Furthermore, schools expose their students to subjects that otherwise might have remained veiled. To become a chemist, you first must know that atoms exist. In school, I’ve learned to share, play nice, and create friendships. These are life skills. In second grade, I made my friend Kelly cry because I told her I was prettier than her. Not only was this statement selfish, it was rude and untrue. I felt awful for quite some time. So, at seven, I came to know that praising yourself is horribly self-absorbed and, often times, hurtful. Without school, this lesson, and other lessons like it, would have come later in life. Through school, we learn to interact with people everyday. We learn to suppress our feelings around those we do not like, and we learn to value the friendships we are able to make. In kindergarten, there was a kid named Jeff in my class. Jeff was reclusive and quiet. He never wanted to play blocks with me. The next year, when I was in first grade, Jeff was still in kindergarten. He had been held back because, as my mother later found out, he wasn’t considered “socially ready” for first grade. School is tedious, and this needs to be, and can be, changed. School, however, should not be abolished all together for a multitude of reasons, including, but not limited to, how it teaches social skills.
I absolutely believe that schooling is necessary. Twelve years of it is extreme, but elementary and secondary schools are certainly essential. As Gatto mentions, schools teach their pupils to respect authority and follow directions, skills necessary to maintain jobs. He fails, though, to recognize that schools provide an environment in which to learn social skills and acquire friendships. Furthermore, schools expose their students to subjects that otherwise might have remained veiled. To become a chemist, you first must know that atoms exist. In school, I’ve learned to share, play nice, and create friendships. These are life skills. In second grade, I made my friend Kelly cry because I told her I was prettier than her. Not only was this statement selfish, it was rude and untrue. I felt awful for quite some time. So, at seven, I came to know that praising yourself is horribly self-absorbed and, often times, hurtful. Without school, this lesson, and other lessons like it, would have come later in life. Through school, we learn to interact with people everyday. We learn to suppress our feelings around those we do not like, and we learn to value the friendships we are able to make. In kindergarten, there was a kid named Jeff in my class. Jeff was reclusive and quiet. He never wanted to play blocks with me. The next year, when I was in first grade, Jeff was still in kindergarten. He had been held back because, as my mother later found out, he wasn’t considered “socially ready” for first grade. School is tedious, and this needs to be, and can be, changed. School, however, should not be abolished all together for a multitude of reasons, including, but not limited to, how it teaches social skills.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)