Thursday, April 16, 2009
Gay Marriage
I don’t understand much about the world. I don’t understand the human immune system, and I’ll never comprehend why some animals eat their young. Physics remains a mystery to me, and the cruel duo of greed and ignorance will continue to baffle me. I do, however, understand love. Love binds us to our neighbors and our families, creating bonds of affection and fraternity that can further the human race and infuse life with purpose. Love can cause war and demand peace, and it can corrupt and it can make whole, but its existence is undeniable and ultimately rich in purpose. For love to be denied is to deny a basic right. Marriage, a basic expression of love, should be allowed to all who seriously seek it. Marriage was once denied to African-Americans and prisoners, and these groups are now able to wed whom they please, a right that is still denied to gay couples. It is an outrage and a shame that a committed gay couple cannot express their love through marriage. True, this does not personally affect me, but I still find it horrible that all cannot openly and legally marry. I believe that if you love someone wholly and want to commit your life to that person, you should be able to marry him or her. I’m not religious, so I don’t particularly believe in sin, and I certainly don’t believe it’s wrong to love someone if that’s who you think you’re called to love. Besides, wasn’t it Jesus who preached acceptance and love for thy neighbor? I don’t want to offend or insult, but I don’t think He would approve of the way we treat our gay friends and neighbors.
Wednesday, April 15, 2009
A Bicycle Built for Two
As explained by Wolfson in the beginning of “What is Marriage,” marriage has several implications, depending on culture and context. Wolfson explains that marriage is indeed a declaration of “love and dedication to another person (99),” but it is also “a relationship between a couple and the government (100).” The author seeks to show that marriage is complicated and important, for only an important thing has so many definitions. When Wolfson later introduces the topic of same-sex marriage, he wants the reader to remember the definitions, to show what gay couples are forced to forgo. I don’t know much about marriage, but I do know some about happiness, and Wolfson’s explanation of marriage seems thoughtful and rings true. He writes, “For better or for worse, marriage is about choice, whether it be the choice to ‘make it official’ with your beloved and to accept the protections and the responsibilities that accompany that decision; the choice to work at your marriage and make it rewarding and good; the choice to betray or divorce a spouse; or the choice to avoid the institution of marriage altogether (101).” I hadn’t thought about the choice that comes with marriage because choice is so linked with marriage, it blends with it. Marriage comes when a couple decides to wed, and a marriage lasts when a couple decides to remain true.
Monday, April 13, 2009
All the Single Parents
According to Dr. Wade Horn, a single-parent household is like an airplane that sometimes fails to reach its destination. A two-parent household, on the other hand, always reaches the airport. The author of the essay, Santorum, uses Dr. Horn to explain why single-parent homes are a threat to children, although single parent homes certainly aren’t the abomination Santorum makes them out to be. Single-parent households, like two-parent households, can be loving, stable environments. When Santorum points to facts that show that children in single-parent households are depressed, he fails to analyze the data, leading to the downfall of his argument. He fails to acknowledge why these kids have a single parent. Perhaps their parents have gone through a divorce, or their mother has died, or their father is fighting for a year in Afghanistan. All these circumstances can cause depression. Perhaps it’s not the single parent situation that causes the depression or bad grades or drug use; perhaps the situation that led to the single parent is the cause. Even then, single parents are often quite adept. They’ve learned to make a turkey sandwich for their kindergartner while on a business call. Or their children have quickly learned independence, and they spread mayonnaise on their own sandwich in the morning. The frazzled single mom who bails on her son’s soccer match does exist, but she’s not as prolific as Santorum seems to suggest.
Sunday, April 12, 2009
Appearances
In Vázquez’s “Appearances,” she waits to reveal that Brian and Mickey are straight men. She knows that the reader will assume they are gay, so that when she announces their actual sexual orientation, it will shock the reader. Interestingly enough, she talks about Mickey’s girlfriend before she reveals his heterosexuality, slightly lessening the “reveal” when it comes. She does eventually bluntly state his and Brian’s sexuality in an attempt to show that “gay men look like all men and all men look like gay men (476).” It makes the reader aware to the fact that antigay feelings can negatively affect heterosexuals and homosexuals. Vázquez tells the story of Tom and Jan Matarrase to further her point. When out for a walk one evening, the married couple was attacked by a group of men who thought they were a gay couple. Vázquez desperately wants her readers to know that anyone can be a victim of antigay violence. If straight men like Mickey and Tom can be attacked for simply looking gay, how can we protect those who actually are gay? The menace of antigay feelings seems much more potent when some of its victims aren’t even part of the targeted group.
Thursday, April 9, 2009
Transcendentalism
During camp at Turtle Island, Eustace Conway teaches his young students to cut off a lock of their hair whenever they cut a branch off a tree. In this way, Conway is spiritual. He believes living things should be respected, but he does not worship trees or revere deer. He is thankful for their existence, and in heightened moments he praises their existence, but he never prays to them. He prays to a god, but he is not particularly religious or devout. Conway is a practical man and seeks sense. Nature is both useful and beautiful to him, but he does not wallow in its poetry. Because he does not see nature as a divine being, Conway is not a transcendentalist. He is too rational to believe in transcendentalism’s romantic version of the woods. He does accept transcendentalism’s view that we should live in nature, but his drive to spread this message forces him to become an outgoing businessman, a role most transcendentalists would loathe.
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
Nature
In “Nature,” Emerson writes, “The sun illuminates only the eye of the man, but shines into the eye and the heart of the child. The lover of nature is he whose inward and outward senses are still truly adjusted to each other; who has retained the spirit of infancy even into the era of manhood.” Further in the essay, he writes, “In the woods too, a man casts off his years, as the snake his slough, and at what period soever of life, is always a child. In the woods, is perpetual youth.” In Emerson’s ludicrous essay, these are the only sentences that make sense. After imparting some wisdom, he goes on to spew drivel about nodding to vegetables and becoming an eyeball. The first parts of his essay, however, are insightful. As children, we make forts and hike in the woods and create memories. When, as an adult, we return to these places of sanctuary and innocence, we relive and remember these memories. The woods remind us of youth, rekindling the feelings of immortality, happiness, and carelessness we once so easily felt as children. Emerson is right in stating that “In the woods… a man… is always a child.” He quickly deteriorates into blather, however, when he writes, “[In nature,] I become a transparent eye-ball; I am nothing; I see all; the currents of the Universal Being circulate through me; I am part of particle of God.” This is something Chris McCandless would highlight in his yellow highlighter and savor. He would make notes near the phrase and bask in its inspiration. To me, the statement, and the whole rest of “Nature,” romanticize and complicate trees and dirt. Forests do allow us experience a pure world close to God’s ideal, but I feel no connection to a god when I swat mosquitoes swarming about my head and whack overhanging branches blocking my path. When Emerson writes, “The greatest delight which the fields and woods minister, is the suggestion of an occult relation between man and the vegetable. I am not alone and unacknowledged. They nod to me, and I to them,” “Nature” reveals itself as a mawkish orgy of pseudo-religious superfluousness. Trees drenched in sunlight are beautiful, but Emerson finds purpose and religion too readily in their beauty. His outpouring of love for mud, sticks, and moss are not just overly sentimental, they’re almost insulting. Could Emerson detect God’s work in the wake of a tornado? Would he be able to find poetry in the smoke of a forest fire? Not all things born of nature are precious or reasonable. When one tries to find purpose in something disastrous, explanations are sought for things that cannot be explained. Emerson found purpose in the flutter of leaves; would he be able to find purpose in tragic deaths like Chris McCandless’s ? Not all things have a purpose.
Monday, April 6, 2009
Why, Gilbert, why?
Elizabeth Gilbert greatly admires Eustace Conway. She respects his way of life and how he has attempted to complete his dreams. Eustace’s Turtle Island impresses and amazes her. She is in awe of him, which is clear from her first meeting with Eustace, when she meets him in New York. She writes, “It seemed curious to me that somebody who eats possum and wipes his butt with leaves could have managed to acquire a thousand acres of pristine wilderness. But Eustace Conway was, as I would discover, a most cunning man (11).” Later in the book, she writes, “My initial reaction on witnessing Eustace Conway’s life was relief. When I first heard of his life and his adventures, all I could think was Thank God. Thank God somebody in America was still living this way. Thank God there was at least one genuine mountain man, frontiersman, pioneer, maverick out there (125).” Her use of “maverick” and “cunning” show the scope of her admiration. Gilbert is taken with Conway and so wants to spread his story. She thinks readers will find Conway compelling, and so her story benefits both Conway and readers, by informing readers about this Man of Destiny and by giving Conway free publicity, to use a crude term. Gilbert also seems to want to challenge herself as a writer. Conway is a complicated man, one who is both pitiable and admirable. Readers may dislike Conway, with his narcissism and his perfectionism, but they can also be swept up in Gilbert’s terms of affection and see Conway as respectable, strong, and tender. Gilbert, by writing "The Last American Man," challenged herself to present a full picture of Eustace Conway’s personality, with all his faults and merits, and she tried to explain both his cruel streak and his gentle side. One could argue she tries to get the reader to see Conway as she sees him, but I think she mostly wanted to write a character study about a man whom she finds great.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)