Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Death of a Salesman Discussion Question

Do you think Willy's suicide was selfish? Was it right for him to end his life? Consider the family he leaves behind.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Speeches Part Deux

Aside from the fact that after my speech, I wanted to bathe in nail polish remover and use a skunk as a loofah, today's speeches were kind of fantastic. The presentation about the Julian Center was very compelling and interesting. I liked how Elise didn't use the lectern, so she was free to move around, creating something to look at besides someone's nervous hand gestures. I also liked how Elise used the story of Grace to introduce the Julian Center's importance. I thought the facts Elise chose to use in her speech really helped to make her argument. I was especially intrigued by the fact that there are more animal shelters than domestic abuse shelters in the Indianapolis area. Henry's use of humor in his speech about Keeping Indianapolis Beautiful made his speech more amusing than others. I also liked Daniel's speech because he too didn't use the lectern, making him seem more open to the audience. After the speeches were made, I felt that several organizations deserved my money, but I ended up giving a large chunk of my donor bucks to one organization that seemed more important than all the rest.

Monday, October 13, 2008

Today's Speeches

I managed to dodge the speech bullet today, and I'm glad of it. The speeches made today would have put my speech to shame. My speech seemed childish in comparison to the well-researched presentation given by JP, and my writing seemed unemotional when looked at after Amy's speech. Speaking in front of a group of jaded high-schoolers is obviously not easy nor fun, but today's group was professional and calm when voicing their information and thoughts to the class. I noticed how essentially all the speakers used an appeal to pathos, and some used an appeal to ethos. Many used quotes and statistics from studies to fortify their argument. Although the statistics were somewhat boring, especially if mentioned in the middle of the speech, they did make the speaker appear more knowledgeable about their charity. I applaud the speakers today for their well-written speeches and for their obvious labor.

Thursday, October 9, 2008

An Update

I've worked for awhile on this project, and I feel confident that my speech will be a good one. Habitat for Humanity, the organization I've decided to rally behind, is an organization I am familiar with and trust. It was difficult to come up with a rebuttal, but I think my rebuttal is a question that's often posed when dealing with charities that handle those down on their luck. This weekend I'm going to do research into home equities, and I will read more studies that revolve around poverty and how a home can ease the strains of poverty. And then I will give my speech. And win.


Claim: Habitat for Humanity is an organization one should give money to.

Reasons: Because Habitat for Humanity provides homes to those unable to buy a typical home in their area and to those whose homes have been destroyed by means of natural disaster. Because Habitat for Humanity recruits teenage and adult volunteers to create a sense of community. Because Habitat for Humanity does not simply give away homes- the recipients of the homes help build them, and the new owners eventually pay back Habitat for Humanity, allowing more homes to be built for those in need. Because Habitat for Humanity uses local materials to build homes, stimulating the local economy. Because the homes built by Habitat for Humanity are environmentally friendly, cost-efficient, and safe.

Warrant: Homes provide a secure place to raise a family. When one lives under a stable roof, they are more likely to be healthy and more likely to be safe. A person is more likely to be hired for a job if they are able to provide an address of residence. Owning a home not only gives the owner a sense of pride and accomplishment, owning a home increases one’s wealth through means of equity and savings resulting from mortgage payments.

Backing: Personal testimony from volunteers and recipients of homes. Statistics- Planning and Development Collaborative International 2006 report, Emory University 2001 report, UN 2003 report, National Low Income Housing Coalition 2004 report. Research- How do equities work?

Rebuttal: Habitat for Humanity gives away free homes to recipients of welfare.

Qualifier: Habitat for Humanity does not gift homes to those in need. People who come to Habitat for Humanity usually are working people who, due to harsh circumstances, take in an income 30 to 50 percent less than their area’s median income. Habitat homeowners are required to make a $500 down payment on their home and are asked to help in the construction of their home. Usually, a Habitat for Humanity home recipient contributes 300 to 500 hours to the making of their home. Furthermore, many Habitat homeowners go on to become volunteers of the organization.

Monday, October 6, 2008

Thoughts on Charity

Although I’m not too enthusiastic about speaking in front of more than three people, I do like this assignment. Charities better our nation and help those in need. Betterment is necessary, and therefore charities are an essential part of our society.
My parents have always been generous, donating money and time to charities like AMVETS and Planned Parenthood. As a child, I helped my elementary school raise money for Riley’s Children Hospital, and I loved walking around my neighborhood, picking up trash. As a Girl Scout, helping those in need has become a habit.
I’m researching into several organizations that I think are worthy of note. I was contemplating writing about Crystal House, an organization that feeds the homeless, but was unable to find any recent information about this charity’s strides. Perhaps Crystal House is no more? There are many praise-worthy charities that exist in Indiana or have chapters in Indiana, so this will be difficult.
As for my speech, well, I’ve never been one for public speaking, but I know this is a fear I must conquer. I fully intend to appeal to pathos, as feelings are both powerful and convincing. I also plan to cite statistics on Indianapolis homeless numbers and other such facts as an appeal to logos. I’m eager to see what other charities people plan on researching.

Sunday, October 5, 2008

Bucking the Trend

Emerson’s lengthy exploration of self-reliance basically states that one must reject conformity, and one must rely on their intuition. In the beginning of his piece, Emerson writes, “To believe your own thought, to believe that what is true for you in your private heart is true for all men, — that is genius.” He goes on to write, “Trust thyself: every heart vibrates to that iron string.” Emerson repeats this advice throughout his essay. He ends by writing, “Nothing can bring you peace but yourself.” By finishing the essay on this strong note, Emerson clearly states his belief that, “Nothing is at last sacred but the integrity of your own mind.”
Emerson evidently believes that the rejection of conformity and the embrace of intuition will ensure success. He says to reject conformity because what is right for others may not necessarily right for you. Emerson also hints that your refusal to conform may bring you prosperity. For example, at one time, many Americans held stock in a company known as Enron. My parents felt uncomfortable investing in this popular energy company and refused to purchase its stock. When Enron went under after a series of scandals and poor business decisions, my parents were certainly glad they had ignored the Enron trend.
Emerson writes, “When we have new perception, we shall gladly disburden the memory of its hoarded treasures as old rubbish. When a man lives with God, his voice shall be sweet as the murmur of the brook and the rustle of the corn.” With this sentence and a succession of similar sentences, Emerson is explaining that when a man trusts in God, this man’s intuitions and “gleams of light” will have come from God. “My friend suggested, ‘But these impulses may be from below, not from above.’ I replied, ‘They do not seem to me to be such; but if I am the Devil’s child, I will live then from the Devil.’” If Emerson’s reactions came from the Devil, he would have to worship the Devil because the inspiration for these moments of genius is an inspiration worth of praise. However, it is Emerson’s belief that our intuition comes from God, and therefore we should follow our urges because they are from the Man himself.
While following your heart and rejecting conformity are nice messages, they are messages difficult to observe. Sometimes gut reactions turn out to be false— just think of the first impressions we have of other people. These snap decisions often turn out to be untrue. Or we don’t trust ourselves enough to obey our intuition. It’s even harder to reject conformity. Although many of us claim to do this successfully, we usually end up submitting to the laws and opinions of others. Our ancestors were forced to adapt to the wills of others to survive. Quite simply, we naturally to want to please others. It’s fascinating to read about conformity; countless studies have been conducted to research into the matter. The results, with slight variations, show that it’s much more natural to go along with everybody else. Conformity is possible to refuse, but it takes a strong will to break chains. Emerson writes lovely sentences, but his advice is ultimately hard to accept.

Thursday, October 2, 2008

Class in America

This essay does not state or hint that the rich are exploiting the poor. As stated explicitly in the text, “One is not rich because the other is poor (309).” As Mantsios writes, “Class standing, and consequently life chances, are largely determined at birth (320).” The rich do not cause the poor to be indigent. Birth standing, as well as education, race, and luck, are factors that can either make or break a person. Mantsios discusses that “class standing has a significant impact on our chances of survival (318).”
He goes on to write about how people who toil in low-wage jobs have lower life expectancies than those who work in high-paying positions. This statement makes sense, but then the author writes about how “the higher [a] student’s social status, the higher the probability that he or she will get higher grades (319).” I can assume many reasons for this occurrence, citing how teenagers living in poor families will often take on a job or somehow assist in household responsibilities. I can assume these reasons are true because of Cheryl Mitchell’s profile on page 316.
Mitchell is a black woman currently working as a nurse’s aide at a municipal hospital. Before holding her current post, Mitchell was employed at several places, including working as a supermarket checker. She was just seventeen when she held her first full-time job as a counter clerk at a local bakery. She was forced to take on this job after she left college due to financial difficulties. Abandoning her dream of becoming a social worker, Mitchell took on her low-paying nurse’s aide post to be able to take care of her son and mother. Had she not had to drop out of college to take in an income, Mitchell might have been able to earn a degree, but, as cited by Mantsios, “Socioeconomic background… operates independently of academic ability at every stage in the process of educational attainment (319).” Even if Mitchell had made it through college, there is no guarantee she would be successful or even earn good grades. Class standing determines so much in America, from our health to what we’re able to do in our free time, whether we are willing to accept this reality or not.